Navigating gun ownership laws as a medical marijuana patient in New York is challenging due to conflicting state and federal regulations. While New York has legalized medical marijuana, federal law still prohibits marijuana users—whether for medical or recreational purposes—from owning or purchasing firearms. This discrepancy presents significant legal hurdles for individuals who hold both a Medical Marijuana Card New York (MMJ Card NY) and wish to own a gun. For many patients, this raises questions about how to reconcile their legal access to medical marijuana with their desire to exercise their Second Amendment rights.
Federal Laws on Medical Marijuana and Gun Ownership
The core issue lies with the Gun Control Act of 1968 and subsequent federal regulations. Under these laws, marijuana—classified as a Schedule I controlled substance—renders anyone who uses it ineligible to purchase or possess firearms. The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) has reinforced this position through a series of directives that prevent individuals who use marijuana, even for medical purposes, from buying guns.
Specifically, on the ATF’s Form 4473, which is required for all firearms purchases, applicants are asked if they are unlawful users of marijuana or any other controlled substances. Responding “yes” disqualifies you from purchasing a firearm, and falsely answering “no” can lead to severe penalties, including perjury charges and up to 10 years in prison.
This federal law supersedes state laws, meaning that even though New York permits medical marijuana use, you still fall under the federal prohibition if you are a cardholder. In short, holding a NY Medical Marijuana Card disqualifies you from owning or purchasing a gun under federal law.
New York State’s Stance
New York State itself does not specifically prohibit medical marijuana patients from owning firearms; however, it must follow federal regulations on this matter. Thus, licensed firearms dealers in New York are required to adhere to federal law, meaning they will not sell firearms to individuals who disclose that they use marijuana for medical reasons.
New York does require thorough background checks for all firearms purchases, and since the ATF form specifically asks about marijuana use, medical marijuana patients will inevitably face legal barriers when attempting to purchase a firearm. Even though New York’s state law does not actively prevent medical marijuana users from applying for gun ownership, federal law ensures that such applications are denied.
Gun Ownership Before and After Obtaining a Medical Marijuana Card
If you already own firearms and later apply for a New York Medical Marijuana Card, the legal situation becomes more complex. While federal law prohibits marijuana users from possessing firearms, it does not provide clear guidance on what current gun owners should do if they subsequently become medical marijuana patients.
Many medical marijuana patients in this scenario may choose to keep their firearms, believing that they are unlikely to be targeted by federal authorities. However, this is a legally risky decision, as federal law still applies. There are no concrete protections for gun owners who become medical marijuana patients, and they could face prosecution if discovered in possession of both a medical marijuana card and firearms.
In contrast, if you hold a gun license and then decide to apply for a medical marijuana card, your ability to legally retain your firearm license may be in jeopardy. Though New York does not actively track this information or enforce gun surrenders for medical marijuana patients, the federal prohibition still holds. This means that if you hold both licenses, you could potentially face legal complications in the future.
Legal Challenges and Ongoing Court Cases
The conflict between state-level medical marijuana laws and federal gun regulations has sparked numerous legal challenges. Notably, several cases have emerged where medical marijuana patients have argued that federal prohibitions on gun ownership violate their Second Amendment rights.
One such case is Wilson v. Lynch, where the plaintiff challenged the federal government’s ban on gun ownership for medical marijuana patients, arguing that it infringed upon her constitutional rights. However, the courts have consistently upheld the federal ban, with rulings stating that marijuana users, even for medical purposes, are considered “unlawful users of controlled substances” under federal law and are, therefore, prohibited from owning firearms.
While some states have attempted to pass legislation that would allow medical marijuana patients to possess firearms legally, federal law remains the dominant authority on this issue. Thus, until changes are made at the federal level, medical marijuana patients in New York—and in any other state—cannot legally own or purchase guns.
Another high-profile case is Fried v. Garland, which challenges the ATF’s restriction on firearms for medical marijuana patients. Filed in Florida, this case is currently awaiting resolution in the 11th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals. The outcome of this case could have far-reaching implications for gun ownership rights among medical marijuana patients, but until there is a change at the federal level, the ATF’s rules remain enforceable.
Federal Pushback and State Initiatives
Despite federal restrictions, some states are pushing back and advocating for more lenient rules regarding gun ownership for medical marijuana patients. Several states with legal medical marijuana programs have proposed or passed laws aimed at protecting gun rights for patients. For example, in Oklahoma, state lawmakers introduced a bill that would prohibit the denial of gun ownership rights based solely on a person’s status as a medical marijuana patient. However, such state-level initiatives are largely symbolic since federal law still governs firearms regulations.
States like Montana and Missouri have also explored ways to balance the rights of medical marijuana patients with gun ownership. However, these state efforts face the same challenge: federal law supersedes any state legislation regarding firearms. The ongoing legal battles suggest that significant changes in gun ownership laws for medical marijuana patients are unlikely until federal marijuana policy changes.
Consequences of Violating Federal Law
For medical marijuana patients who decide to own firearms despite federal prohibitions, the consequences can be severe. In addition to being denied the right to purchase new firearms, patients found in possession of firearms can face federal charges, including:
•Perjury: If you falsely answer “no” to the question about marijuana use on ATF Form 4473, you could face perjury charges, punishable by up to five years in prison.
•Firearm Possession Penalties: Under federal law, unlawfully possessing a firearm while using marijuana can lead to a sentence of up to 10 years in prison. This applies even if you are legally using medical marijuana in your state.
Medical marijuana patients must carefully consider these risks before purchasing or retaining firearms.
Conclusion
If you are a registered medical marijuana patient in New York, federal law prohibits you from purchasing or owning firearms, despite state-level legalization of medical cannabis. The conflict between state and federal law creates a difficult situation for those who rely on medical marijuana for treatment but also wish to exercise their Second Amendment rights.
For now, patients must weigh the risks of holding both a New York Medical Marijuana Card and a firearm. The safest course of action is to avoid purchasing or possessing firearms while registered as a medical marijuana user. Legal challenges are ongoing, but until federal laws change, medical marijuana patients remain ineligible for gun ownership.